Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Interactivity #2

What we now would call ‘simple’ tools like scales, hotplates, glassware and microscopes were the most influential technological advances for the science classroom. Although such tools weren’t exactly groundbreaking at the time they were introduced, they represented a big leap forward in students' personal ownership of their understanding of science. They not only would receive great hands-on tools to explore concepts with, they'd be individually responsible for knowing how to use and take care of their equipment. The same way that utilizing presentation technology (smartboards, videos, etc.) is empowering for teachers, providing lab equipment to the student alongside support and training was empowering for the students' in self motivated learning.
A theme that kept constantly popping up in both of the readings was the idea that technology has become a medium for corporate meddling. In the late 80’s and early 90’s, donations would be made to get televisions or computers into schools with the only string attached being advertising. From a protectionist viewpoint, Channel One’s advertisements were perceived as inappropriate and almost akin to propaganda, and it’s no surprise that the biggest voices in the educational world like the NEA, national PTA, AFT and others moved to pull it out of the classroom as soon as possible.
One of the biggest reasons I chose to become a Physics teacher is because I believe that learning to see things through a scientific lens is empowering, even to students who think they hate the content. Those who come from more creative fields, like art and literature, often criticize the scientific mind for being too cold or only seeing things one way. But in reality, a mature scientific mind constantly questions the world – we aren’t here to tell students that planets move in the way that they do and that atoms have certain properties, we’re here to cultivate a desire to know how the universe works.
To me, advertisements and propoganda in a student’s life are among the most toxic things that can ruin his or her ability to think creatively and scientifically. It’s worrisome enough that students’ private lives are filled with activities that are saturated with advertisements (television, internet), but to think that that corporations actually tried (and at times succeeded) to get their feet in the door of our schools and program our kids to be consumers… it’s sickening. My job to get a student to think and learn at very high orders of complexity, to get them to a point where they can challenge and modify their own observations and view of the universe, and this all becomes pointless when the student has grown up accustomed to being told what others want him or her to believe. We obviously can't fully control what they're exposed to outside of school that may shift their mindsets, but we need to keep doing our best to make sure they aren't exposed to that influence within the school and perhaps educate them early on how to identify and evaluate propoganda and misinformation that they may be exposed to online and on TV.


                               
Nothing ruins learning the truth like being exposed to an exciting lie.

3 comments:

  1. Brian, interesting photo. Can you help me understand where the technology is and how it relates to schooling?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Kevin!
    In retrospect, I should have elaborated on my train of thought surrounding the picture. The graphic represents a falsehood that can easily be found online – in this case that humans inhabited the earth alongside dinosaurs. Another picture that I was thinking of using had to do with a scam that went around years ago about the concept of a ‘water fueled car’ that magically produced energy out of a repeating hydrolysis cycle. A fair number of people rabidly bought into the craze and insisted that oil companies were conspiring to keep this technological feat a secret. From a scientific perspective, the concept was completely thermodynamically unsound and to anyone with enough education, it was obviously a complete farce. In the same way, most high schoolers would know that humans and dinosaurs never lived on Earth at the same time but a five year old who saw an exciting movie where the two were together might be confused on the matter. In the end, to someone without enough information, either of these concepts could pass as truth. The vast amount of false and misleading information made available online is a technological advance that has had a massive impact (for worse) on how students’ minds react to exploring scientific theories in a classroom today.

    ReplyDelete